Would you rather (2)

[wellingaway]

Option 1

A 33 year old Andy Collett


Option 2

A 33 year old Craig Liddle


Option 3

A 33 year old Marco Gabiadini

[Bogratsteve]

Got to be 3, Gabba would rip the league apart & make Cartmans seasons tally look like he scored as many as that Flop Fisher

[ArmchairDiehard]

Gabbers for me too

[lo36789]

Gabbiadini all day long

[poppyfield]

What does Marco Gabbiadini do these days, hung his boots up or still playing? anybody.

[Bogratsteve]

Owns a hotel in York and pundit sometimes I think

[lo36789]

hung his boots up or still playing?

Still playing? He's 47!

I think he might be involved in an agency as well. He seems to tweet quite regularly about going to the academies of clubs and signing up 15/16 year olds.

[Spyman]

Option 1

A 33 year old Andy Collett


Option 2

A 33 year old Craig Liddle


Option 3

A 33 year old Marco Gabiadini

I'm not sure I understand the question.

Andy Collet had retired from playing by the age of 33.
Craig Liddle retired when he was 33 having spent a lot of time out injured.
Marco Gabbiadini had left us for Northampton, where he was still playing regular League football.

So on that basis, it is a bit of a no-brainer. Gabbiadini was the only one still playing professional football at the age of 33 whereas the other two had retired.

[wellingaway]

Option 1

A 33 year old Andy Collett


Option 2

A 33 year old Craig Liddle


Option 3

A 33 year old Marco Gabiadini

I'm not sure I understand the question.

Andy Collet had retired from playing by the age of 33.
Craig Liddle retired when he was 33 having spent a lot of time out injured.
Marco Gabbiadini had left us for Northampton, where he was still playing regular League football.

So on that basis, it is a bit of a no-brainer. Gabbiadini was the only one still playing professional football at the age of 33 whereas the other two had retired.

You don't understand the question? You should probably not take part then. It's not massively difficult to follow.

[Spyman]

Option 1

A 33 year old Andy Collett


Option 2

A 33 year old Craig Liddle


Option 3

A 33 year old Marco Gabiadini

I'm not sure I understand the question.

Andy Collet had retired from playing by the age of 33.
Craig Liddle retired when he was 33 having spent a lot of time out injured.
Marco Gabbiadini had left us for Northampton, where he was still playing regular League football.

So on that basis, it is a bit of a no-brainer. Gabbiadini was the only one still playing professional football at the age of 33 whereas the other two had retired.

You don't understand the question? You should probably not take part then. It's not massively difficult to follow.

Well it just seems a bit of a non-question - two of them had retired through injury by the age of 33.

[wellingaway]

You're missing a bit before that too. It's all hypothetical from start to finish. It's not going to happen - just a bit of Friday time wasting really. No need for a reasoned thesis.

[Spyman]

You're missing a bit before that too. It's all hypothetical from start to finish. It's not going to happen - just a bit of Friday time wasting really. No need for a reasoned thesis.

As I said then, Gabbiadini. Because the other two weren't much use as players at 33!

Out of interest, why 33?

All three at 29 might be an interesting comparison - Gabbas just before he joined us and his career seemed to be on the slide - although as it turned out still had loads in his locker, while Liddle and Collett were probably at the peak of their powers.

[wellingaway]

Ok, as it's Friday afternoon, you can have 29 if it makes you happy. Don't tell anyone else though.

[Darlo_Pete]

If they were all fit, seeing we're all talking hypothetically, then I'd go and Andy Collett. Fantastic keeper.